Note: The other languages of the website are Google-translated. Back to English
Masuk  \/ 
x
or
x
Daftar  \/ 
x

or

Bagaimana cara mencegah penyimpanan jika sel tertentu kosong di Excel?

Misalnya, Anda mendesain formulir di lembar kerja dan berbagi dengan kolega Anda. Anda berharap kolega Anda mengisi nama mereka ke dalam sel tertentu untuk menunjukkan siapa yang memasukkan formulir ini, jika tidak mencegah mereka menyimpan formulir, bagaimana Anda bisa melakukannya? Di sini saya akan memperkenalkan makro VBA untuk mencegah penyimpanan buku kerja jika sel tertentu kosong di Excel.

Tab Office Mengaktifkan Pengeditan dan Penjelajahan Tab di Office, dan Jadikan Pekerjaan Anda Lebih Mudah ...
Kutools for Excel Memecahkan Sebagian Besar Masalah Anda, dan Meningkatkan Produktivitas Anda hingga 80%
  • Gunakan Kembali Apa Pun: Tambahkan rumus, bagan, dan hal lain yang paling sering digunakan atau rumit ke favorit Anda, dan gunakan kembali dengan cepat di masa mendatang.
  • Lebih dari 20 fitur teks: Ekstrak Nomor dari String Teks; Ekstrak atau Hapus Bagian dari Teks; Ubah Angka dan Mata Uang ke Kata Bahasa Inggris.
  • Gabungkan Alat: Beberapa Buku Kerja dan Lembar menjadi Satu; Gabungkan Beberapa Sel / Baris / Kolom Tanpa Kehilangan Data; Gabungkan Baris dan Jumlah Duplikat.
  • Alat Pisah: Membagi Data Menjadi Beberapa Lembar Berdasarkan Nilai; Satu Buku Kerja ke Beberapa File Excel, PDF atau CSV; Satu Kolom ke Beberapa Kolom.
  • Tempel Melewati Baris Tersembunyi / Difilter; Hitung Dan Jumlah dengan Warna Latar Belakang; Kirim Email Hasil Personalisasi ke Beberapa Penerima secara Massal.
  • Filter Super: Buat skema filter tingkat lanjut dan terapkan ke setiap lembar; Jenis menurut minggu, hari, frekuensi, dan lainnya; Menyaring dengan tebal, rumus, komentar ...
  • Lebih dari 300 fitur canggih; Bekerja dengan Office 2007-2019 dan 365; Mendukung semua bahasa; Penerapan yang mudah di perusahaan atau organisasi Anda.


panah gelembung kanan biruCegah penyimpanan jika sel tertentu kosong di Excel

Untuk mencegah menyimpan buku kerja saat ini jika sel tertentu kosong di Excel, Anda dapat menerapkan makro VBA berikut dengan mudah.

Langkah 1: Buka jendela Microsoft Visual Basic for Applications dengan menekan lain + F11 kunci sementara.

Langkah 2: Di Project Explorer, perluas file VBAProject (Nama buku kerja Anda.xlsm) serta Objek Microsoft Excel, lalu klik dua kali file Buku Kerja Ini. Lihat tangkapan layar kiri:

Langkah 3: Di jendela pembuka ThisWorkbook, tempel makro VBA berikut:

Makro VBA: Mencegah penyimpanan jika sel tertentu kosong

Private Sub Workbook_BeforeSave(ByVal SaveAsUI As Boolean, Cancel As Boolean)
If Application.Sheets("TEST").Range("A1").Value = "" Then
Cancel = True
MsgBox "Save cancelled"
End If
End Sub
Catatan: Dalam kode VBA, "TEST" adalah nama lembar kerja tertentu, dan "A1"adalah sel spesifik, dan Anda dapat mengubahnya sesuai kebutuhan.

Sekarang jika sel tertentu kosong di buku kerja saat ini, saat Anda menyimpannya, kotak dialog peringatan akan keluar dan memberi tahu Anda "Simpan dibatalkanLihat screen shot berikut ini:


panah gelembung kanan biruArtikel terkait


Alat Produktivitas Kantor Terbaik

Kutools for Excel Memecahkan Sebagian Besar Masalah Anda, dan Meningkatkan Produktivitas Anda hingga 80%

  • Reuse: Masukkan dengan cepat rumus, bagan yang kompleks dan apa pun yang pernah Anda gunakan sebelumnya; Enkripsi Sel dengan kata sandi; Buat Milis dan mengirim email ...
  • Super Formula Bar (dengan mudah mengedit beberapa baris teks dan rumus); Membaca Tata Letak (membaca dan mengedit sel dalam jumlah besar dengan mudah); Tempel ke Rentang yang Difilter...
  • Gabungkan Sel / Baris / Kolom tanpa kehilangan Data; Pisahkan Konten Sel; Gabungkan Baris / Kolom Duplikat... Mencegah Sel Duplikat; Bandingkan Rentang...
  • Pilih Duplikat atau Unik Baris; Pilih Baris Kosong (semua sel kosong); Temukan Super dan Temukan Fuzzy di Banyak Buku Kerja; Pilih Acak ...
  • Salinan Tepat Beberapa Sel tanpa mengubah referensi rumus; Buat Referensi Otomatis ke Beberapa Lembar; Sisipkan Poin, Kotak Centang, dan lainnya ...
  • Ekstrak Teks, Tambahkan Teks, Hapus berdasarkan Posisi, Hapus Space; Membuat dan Mencetak Subtotal Paging; Konversi Konten Antar Sel dan Komentar...
  • Filter Super (simpan dan terapkan skema filter ke sheet lain); Penyortiran Lanjutan menurut bulan / minggu / hari, frekuensi dan lainnya; Filter Khusus dengan huruf tebal, miring ...
  • Gabungkan Workbooks dan WorkSheets; Gabungkan Tabel berdasarkan kolom kunci; Pisahkan Data menjadi Beberapa Lembar; Konversi Batch xls, xlsx dan PDF...
  • Lebih dari 300 fitur canggih. Mendukung Office / Excel 2007-2019 dan 365. Mendukung semua bahasa. Penerapan yang mudah di perusahaan atau organisasi Anda. Fitur lengkap uji coba gratis 30 hari. Jaminan uang kembali 60 hari.
tab kte 201905

Tab Office Membawa antarmuka Tab ke Office, dan Membuat Pekerjaan Anda Jauh Lebih Mudah

  • Aktifkan pengeditan dan pembacaan tab di Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Publisher, Access, Visio, dan Project.
  • Buka dan buat banyak dokumen di tab baru di jendela yang sama, bukan di jendela baru.
  • Meningkatkan produktivitas Anda sebesar 50%, dan mengurangi ratusan klik mouse untuk Anda setiap hari!
officetab bawah
Say something here...
symbols left.
You are guest
or post as a guest, but your post won't be published automatically.
Loading comment... The comment will be refreshed after 00:00.
  • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
    Aditya · 7 months ago
    This is not working, it states save cancelled but still ends up saving the workbook
    • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
      kellytte · 7 months ago
      Note: In the VBA code, the "TEST" is the specific worksheet name, and the "A1" is the specific cell, and you can change them as you need.

      For example, your sheet is named as "Sheet1", and the specified cell is B2, you need to change the sheet name and cell address in the VBA code before running it
  • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
    Happy · 1 years ago
    I tried above formula which works. May i know is there any formula can force user to fill in before they can save? As i set the pull down menu "Please select", "Yes" or "No" for them to select. But they always forgot to select that field and remain "Please select". If i add this VBA code only apply cell is blank. Much appreciate you can advise. Thank you
    • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
      kellytte · 1 years ago
      Hi Happy,
      Just replace the empty value “Sheets("TEST").Range("A1").Value = ""” to the specified text “Sheets("TEST").Range("A1").Value = "Please select"
      And the whole code will be changed as below:

      Private Sub Workbook_BeforeSave(ByVal SaveAsUI As Boolean, Cancel As Boolean) If Application.Sheets("TEST").Range("A1").Value = "Please select" Then Cancel = True MsgBox "Save cancelled" End If End Sub


  • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
    Happy · 1 years ago
    Hi, I tried above formula which works. May i know is there any formula can force user to fill in before they can save? As i set the pull down menu "Please select", "Yes" or "No" for them to select. But they always forgot to select that field and remain "Please select". If i add this VBA code only apply cell is blank. Much appreciate you can advise. Thank you
  • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
    Am1n · 1 years ago
    Hi
    I have a VBA code that sorts and filters data from one excel table and save 48 different reports on my desktop. but based on those filters, some generated reports have only 1 row (headers) and no data. How can I add some VBA code to my file that prevents to save files that has just one row (header) and no data?
    Thank you
  • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
    Amin · 1 years ago
    Hi
    I have a VBA code that sorts and filters data from one excel table and save 48 different reports on my desktop. but based on those filters, some generated reports have only 1 row (headers) and no data. How can I add some VBA code to my file that prevents to save files that has just one row (header) and no data?
    Thank you
  • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
    Benjamin · 2 years ago
    good afternoon, I used the code above and it worked perfectly. my question is what should the code look like if I want to test on 2 cells? I am quite desperate. thanking you I advance for your assistance
  • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
    Yzelle · 2 years ago
    I have a very big spreadsheet that contains a lot of info.
    Can someone please help me with a code to copy into VBA - I want it to be that if Cell C2-C1000+ have any info in them then cell O2-O1000+ and P2-P1000+ requires user input - however if a cell in Column C is empty then the cell in Column O & P can be empty as well. (for example) if cell C3 doesn't have any data input then cell O3-P3 can be empty.

    Thank you :)
    • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
      kellytte · 2 years ago
      Hi Yzelle,
      Please remember to place below code into “ThisWorkbook” script window, and rename the worksheet name “Test” in the below code based on your condition.

      Dim xIRg As Range
      Dim xSRg As Range
      Dim xBol As Boolean
      Dim xInt As Integer
      Dim xStr As String
      If ActiveSheet.Name = "Test" Then
      Set xRg = Range("C:C")
      Set xRRg = Intersect(xRg.Worksheet.UsedRange, xRg)
      xBol = False
      On Error Resume Next
      For xInt = 1 To xRRg.Count
      Set xIRg = xRRg.Item(xInt)
      If xIRg.Value2 <> "" Then
      Set xSRg = Nothing
      If (Range("O" & xIRg.Row) = "") Or (Range("P" & xIRg.Row) = "") Then
      xBol = True
      Exit For
      End If
      End If
      Next
      If xBol Then
      Cancel = True
      MsgBox "Save cancelled"
      End If
      End If
      End Sub
      • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
        Fatos Gaxha · 5 months ago
        Private Sub Workbook_BeforeSave(ByVal SaveAsUI As Boolean, Cancel As Boolean)

        With Sheets("Sheet1")
        If WorksheetFunction.CountA(.Range("A1:A4")) <> WorksheetFunction.CountA(.Range("B1:C4")) / 2 Then
        Cancel = True
        MsgBox "Please enter a values in columns B and C", vbCritical, "Error!"
        End If
        End With

        End Sub


        Just change the range from a to c, and from b to o and p
        hope it will help
      • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
        Fatos Gaxha · 5 months ago
        Private Sub Workbook_BeforeSave(ByVal SaveAsUI As Boolean, Cancel As Boolean)

        With Sheets("Sheet1")
        If WorksheetFunction.CountA(.Range("A1:A4")) <> WorksheetFunction.CountA(.Range("B1:C4")) / 2 Then
        Cancel = True
        MsgBox "Please enter a values in columns B and C", vbCritical, "Error!"
        End If
        End With

        End Sub


        Just change the range from a to c, and from b to o and p
        hope it will help
        • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
          Reece · 2 months ago
          Do you have a way that this can be coded so that either B or C need to be populated but its not required to populate both?
  • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
    andrewgonzales048@gmail.com · 2 years ago
    This is really great. Do you know what I can do to make this work for a range of sheets and a number of cells? Also, these cells cannot always be the same, as there are sheets generated in this specific workbook which may not have the same cell needing to be filled each time. The cells will always be in the same column, just above the page border which is also generated. Thanks!
  • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
    mhoferica@gmail.com · 2 years ago
    Hi, very useful. BUT there is a problem when I use it for files on the sharepoint. The changes are not saved but a new version is created that is displayed when reopening which is quite confusing. Is it possible to disable these new versions ?
  • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
    Wkai · 2 years ago
    Hi i want to ask if it is from A2 to U2. what should i write?
    • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
      kellytte · 2 years ago
      Hi Wkai,
      Try this VBA code:
      (This VBA code will detect Range A2:E5 in the Sheet “Test”, and cancel saving if there are blank cells existing in the range.)

      Private Sub Workbook_BeforeSave(ByVal SaveAsUI As Boolean, Cancel As Boolean)
      Dim xWSName As String
      Dim xRgAddress As String
      Dim xRg As Range
      Dim xWs As Worksheet
      Dim xFNRg As Range
      xWSName = "TEST"
      xRgAddress = "A2:E5"
      Set xWs = Application.ActiveWorkbook.Worksheets.Item(xWSName)
      Set xRg = xWs.Range(xRgAddress)
      Set xFNRg = Nothing
      On Error Resume Next
      Set xFNRg = xRg.SpecialCells(xlCellTypeBlanks, 23)
      If Not TypeName(xFNRg.count) = "Nothing" Then
      Cancel = True
      MsgBox "Save cancelled"
      End If
      End Sub
  • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
    edusuro · 4 years ago
    hi - this was super helpful... Just had one question, how do I save the file without a value in that field? As I try to save, the VBA code will pop the "Save Cancelled" message which is the intended response, however, need to save once without a value to create the form to be reused.

    Thanks!
    • To post as a guest, your comment is unpublished.
      kelly.extendoffice@gmail.com · 4 years ago
      Hi Eduardo,
      What about typing a space in the specified cell to pretend to a blank cell? Please remind to remove the space in future!